Three brokers to consider! Zerodha is a cheap broker, ICICI Direct is a full-service bank and HDFC Sky is a middle ground with a bank backing and fixed pricing. Depending on what you’re looking for in your future option trading this year, let’s look at each one:
How Do Their F&O Charges Compare?
| Feature | Zerodha | ICICI Direct | HDFC SKY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equity futures | ₹20 or 0.03%, lower applies | About 0.03% or tiered plans | ₹20 or 2.5% small, lower applies |
| Equity options | ₹20 per executed order | ₹49 per lot, ₹35 to ₹95 by plan | ₹20 per order |
| Account opening | ₹300 | ₹0 to ₹975 by plan | ₹0 |
| Demat AMC | ₹300 a year, first year free | ₹700 a year, first year free | ₹240 a year, first year free |
| Research | Self service, no research calls | Research access | Expert research picks |
Zerodha and HDFC Sky tie on options at ₹20. ICICI Direct prices by the lot.
What Does the Discount Broker Skip?
Zerodha is designed for people who know exactly what they want. There is no research phone call; however, there is a ₹300 account fee to open a demat account.
What About the Bank Broker?
ICICI Direct has a bank backing, full service and some great plans. Options are charged at ₹49 per lot, but also vary between ₹35-₹95. You will pay a ₹700 demat AMC after the first year. The account setup fee will vary from ₹ 0 to ₹ 975. Prime plans include research content; however, you will have to pay for it up front. This means it uses the old-style pricing structure but is still very good.
What Does HDFC Sky Add?
HDFC Sky is a bank-backed broker with fixed pricing. Options are charged at ₹20 per order, and Futures are charged at ₹20/low percentage. It’s free of charge to open demat account and the demat AMC is around ₹240 after a free first year. The Play Store page says that you can place options and futures with one click, advanced charts and option chain data. It also shows that it has expert advice on when to trade F&O stocks for futures and options trading.
Does Research Matter for F&O?
Yes, it gives you a reason to trade. You will get research from an analyst registered with SEBI. You’ll also have the Payoff Analyzer, Margin Calculator and Strategy Builder to help you calculate how much to put into each position. Zerodha will leave you to do this. ICICI Direct does offer research; however, it is on a plan. HDFC Sky are the only one to offer research at a fixed price.
What Are the Risks?
These contracts can move quickly, so you may lose more money due to a slight price movement. All brokers will have taxes and trading costs on top of your commission. Plan your strategy for each trade, start with one lot and use a stop loss.
Which One Should You Pick?
If you already have ideas, then you should go with Zerodha. Try one lot with each before opening a demat account. If you want bank support, then go with ICICI Direct. If you want bank support, research, tools and advantage of discount pricing, then go with HDFC Sky.
This is generally a better option for most traders. This is general information only and should not be taken as investment advice.